Twin Peaks: “The Return” … To The Dream

It would seem fruitless to write a narrative explication of “Twin Peaks: The Return” and hope that it could thread together every narrative nuance into a cohesive explanation. Such an effort would defy the very principle upon which the universe was forged in the first place. And, to be sure, I am not in a position to provide “answers” to anything necessarily, only thoughts and impressions. Of course, like most people who watch a television show, or read a novel, explanations and epiphanies are desirable. Discovering the underlying truth behind any puzzle can be both a rewarding, and flummoxing, proposition. And, so it is the case here. David Lynch has presented us with so many images and themes in Twin Peaks that many of them overlap and have recursive significance.

It is within this vein that I found myself desirous of writing about aspects of the narrative journey in a free-form format, rather than attempting to provide an over-arching and impossibly conclusive, insightful thesis into an artistic journey that David Lynch perhaps wished to remain intrinsically unanswerable. Such, it would seem, is the beauty and exasperation of the dream world, where associational freedoms take some form of transcendent precedence over the conventions of logical exegesis. It is a glorious space that he was able to explore—that is, a room that may seem lacking in form or substance, but one in which, remarkably, the infinite threads of interpretational fancy are housed. This place, such as the Red Room itself (in either its “White Lodge” or “Black Lodge” iterative manifestation), is where answers and clues seem to be present at every turn, but where the very nature of those answers are ephemeral, backwards, or metaphorical. They are not only metaphorically depicted in the scenes themselves, but also perhaps as the “real Diane” who emerges with red hair and finger nails of alternating black and white, and who seems, in the final analysis, to be a human version of whatever the lodge itself represents, either through color-scheme, purpose, both, or neither.

Kyle MacLachlan in a still from Twin Peaks. Photo: Suzanne Tenner/SHOWTIME

When I look at Twin Peaks in its entirety, rather than as an isolated journey confined to the recent adventures in the “The Return,” I feel an overwhelming sense of beauty, nostalgia, horror, and confusion. These emotions and reactions are woven together in a series of recursive images gleaned from the show itself and, of course, from the natural human emotions that flow from its experience. For example, I see images of Audrey dancing in the “Double R” diner, methodically undulating to a foreboding but gorgeous song that defines her–images from twenty-five years ago where she is lost in a reverie, as perhaps all of us have been, since the moment Twin Peaks appeared on the television screen. And so, I use her character as a starting point, or perhaps even an end point, since sequencing and chronology is ambiguous in the narrative world of Twin Peaks.

I cannot imagine that David Lynch would return to the Audrey Horne narrative in the manner that he did, if it had little to no significance regarding the philosophy of Twin Peaks. Many who have written about “The Return” seem flummoxed by Audrey’s role, as if perhaps her depiction was narratively superfluous or that her dialogue was self-indulgently muddled for the sake of meandering artifice. I contend that this cannot be the case. Indeed, the décor and temporal context of her scenes are of initial interest. She does not seem to be housed in a modern, contemporary setting. Rather, the interior décor and stylizations of her scenes seem closely aligned with the décor of the world occupied by the Fireman/Giant. Furthermore, she appears trapped in a recursive and endless conversation about Billy. These conversations are with a well-dressed midget who seems to function as an exasperated patriarch, more concerned with accounting or even legal issues. After stalling at the threshold for a considerable amount of time, she finally makes her way into the Roadhouse by Episode 16 of “The Return,” where she re-lives her mythic dance. In this brief progression, followed by the traumatic event that follows and the exit music that is played backwards on stage, I believe that we are confronting “the dreamer.” We are confronting a character trapped in the liminal divide between conscious realization and schizophrenic delusion. This harkens, of course, to the dream that Gordon Cole had, wherein Monica Bellucci tells him that: “We are like the dreamer who dreams, and then lives inside the dream. But who is the dreamer?” Precisely. Throughout the history of literature, the artist’s self-reflexive depictions of himself or herself within the fabric of their art itself often provide the most conclusive answers to the text’s existential crises–and what better way to convey the intent and truth of the Twin Peaks world-view than through the optic lens and “dream” of Gordon Cole, who functions not just as the head of the FBI but the creative mind behind Twin Peaks itself?

It could be theorized that Audrey is the dreamer, and her dream is the dream, or hallucination, that we have been lost within the entire time. Yet, isn’t it narratively insufficient to conclude that everything is in her head and/or is the sole product of a rape encounter with the Evil Cooper? What about everything that preceded that moment in narrative? It is perhaps enough to view Audrey’s state as metaphorical for a broader state of consciousness. Critically, certain lines of key dialogue that she utters to Charlie (“is this the story of the little girl who lived down the lane? Is it?”) are reiterated, verbatim, by “The Arm” in the “Black Lodge” to Dale Cooper in the Finale of Episode 18. This suggests a tremendous amount about her significance to the overall construct of Twin Peaks.

Following Audrey’s narrative, many clues emerge. For example, the connection between Richard Horne’s parentage comes to fruition in the moments before his electrifying death, and we have enough evidence to presume that, much in the same way as with Diane, Evil Cooper likely preyed upon fear in an effort to gain sexual access to Audrey. Whether that, in and of itself, was capable of de-stabilizing Audrey psychologically in and of itself can only be presumed, because the direct narrative consequences of whatever happened to her, or with her, are never overtly revealed. Thus, though it would seem to be altogether too convenient to necessarily premise the entire Twin Peaks experience from start to finish as being the product of Audrey’s imagination, there is sufficient evidence to suggest that it is the case. Specifically, Audrey’s “dream,” or psychosis, encompasses many of the inherent elements that we have come to associate with Twin Peaks from the outset—i.e., multiple personalities, doppelgangers, the mystery and intrigue of FBI government investigations, conspiracy, sex, prostitution, an astrophysical force that controls our motivations, the disassociation and disaster of family, betrayal, and the shocking horror of an esteemed FBI idol turned rapist.

In my view, there is merit to the interpretation that, within the fabric of Audrey’s dream, there are two central manifestations that are evident from “The Return”: (1) the intoxicating soundtrack and collection of wayward narratives and dialogue that occur at the Roadhouse, as akin to her endless dialogues with Charlie, who is more than likely the embodiment of a therapist; and (2) the dark underbelly of a stark white room, which seems to suggest, in a flash, her real confinement in a psych ward. The split second that we see Audrey in the white room is the brief moment when the entire veneer and fabric of Twin Peaks has been ripped from us, and we have become momentarily privy to the blinding reality beneath it all.

Whatever is “real” and whatever is “imagination” in Twin Peaks is a self-reflexive conundrum—that is, the result of questions whose labyrinthine answers only manage to produce more questions. Though, such is the path of the human consciousness, is it not? As such, I could hypothesize, in her dream, Audrey was raped by Evil Cooper at some point in the past, and that, as a result of the trauma she suffered and the birth of Richard Horne, she has disassociated and is now trapped in a world of sprawling ideations and mythologies borne of psychological confinement – a liminal existence of beauty and terror that is both her reality and her illness.

To that end, her wild and circuitous ramblings about “Billy” could be theorized as nothing more than pointless banter, but, more realistically, they are the desperate figments of a broken mind that is seeking narrative mythology to occupy, define, and in a sense remediate the unresolvable throes of mental illness. Thus, we are made to believe that the exasperated indulgences of her therapist are manifested as the likeness of an intractable, midget accountant—i.e., one whose nettlesome, clinical objective is to assess the whims, needs, and aberrant thought patterns of someone who is mentally ill. After all, this makes sense. In whatever can be theorized as the “real world” in Twin Peaks, we do know that Audrey’s father, Benjamin Horne, has been depicted as a patriarch who is called upon to resolve the woes of his family members with money. It would seem apropos, therefore, that Audrey is left to fend for herself with hired mental health care professionals, rather than with an impatient, and frankly, exhausted father who has excused himself from the morass. He too, we recall, was in the throes of mental illness in Season 2, and his personality crisis imported him into the character of General Robert E. Lee, with his only salvation from the self-imposed “civil war” being his efforts to re-write history and emerge victorious as the commander of the southern forces.

Ultimately, to find narrative cohesion, or “answers,” in such imagery would be to effectively define a narrative that seems, in hindsight, to be a canvas of associations—whether or not they are solely from Audrey’s perspective. The whole world of Twin Peaks has really been, if anything, a deeply complex arena of beauty and madness that has been progressively evolving within the mind of its creators. A journey that is the product of the often complex, and the often banal, courses of the human conscoiusness.

An example of the evolving mythology of the human consciousness takes us back to Season 2. If I were to turn back time and ask David Lynch what he meant by several images and depictions from twenty-five years ago, I might receive an anachronistic response that meant something tangible to him in the early nineties. For example, I return to a particular scene from Season 2, Episode 19, that has resonated with me for twenty-five years. I refer to the scene in which Windom Earle makes his way into Owl Cave, after having surreptitiously followed Cooper, Deputy Andy, Hawk, and Sheriff Truman to the mysterious location. When Deputy Andy accidently fumbles with his axe, and it makes contact with the petroglyph avatar of fire, one of the characteristic diamond symbols in the petroglyph shakes loose, revealing a knob that is oriented in – what would seem to be – its natural position. However, when Windom Earle gains access to Owl Cave, he turns the knob and, in effect, inverts the symbol into the evil symbol that we have been provided all throughout “The Return.” What follows at the tail end of Season Two is Dale Cooper’s journey into the Black Lodge, and a characteristic form of palsy, or shaking, that seems to have afflicted the residents of Twin Peaks. It is as if the natural order has been inverted, and now a characteristic imbalance, or evil, has been unleashed into the world. Yet, of course, this evil was not unleashed for the first time at this moment when Earle turned the handle. It is as old as time itself, or at least has certain elemental underpinnings in the Manhattan Project. Of course, not knowing the answer to Lynch and Frost’s intent in the nineties, I could imagine that a discussion of “good versus evil” would have ensued twenty-five years ago, and that the Black Lodge was a mere foil to the White Lodge, and that in turning the symbol, perhaps access to the inverted evil that is the Black Lodge was made possible at Glastonbury Grove, rather like a portal to great suffering and sorrow.

But, as with any narrative, the philosophy of Twin Peaks has had a chance to evolve. The canvas of Twin Peaks has become broader and more complex over the span of twenty-five years, and Lynch’s artistic dabblings into historical notions of “good versus evil” have evolved from mere colorizations of “black” and “white,” and polarizing lodges and waypoints, to complex philosophical imagery that evokes principles of both astrophysics and existentialism. This, of course, leads inexorably to a brief discussion of Episode 8 of “The Return,” which takes us back to 5:29 a.m., on July 16, 1945, and the detonation of the A-bomb as part of the Manhattan Project (cue Penderecki’s “Threnody for the Victims of Hiroshima”). It would be provisional to suggest that Lynch and Frost were somehow suggesting that pure evil was born in this watershed moment of United States history, much like it would be provincial to suggest that Window Earle unleashed evil into the physical universe by turning a handle in a cave. However, these separate occurrences and depictions do seem to suggest that, on some subatomic level, the pure evil that was inherent in the bomb’s theoretical creation managed to uncouple the molecular composition of space-time once it was detonated, resulting in what Gordon Cole and Phillip Jeffries referred to as “Judy.”

The implication that I believe is being conveyed is that the Manhattan Project in Episode 8 caused a “breach,” or rift, to open in the physical universe, which permitted sorrow (“garmonbozia”/creamed corn) to infiltrate the natural world in a new and different way than it has otherwise previously existed. This is rather like the sudden breach, or rift, that we see in a shocking moment of clarity in the Roadhouse when Audrey confronts herself in a stark white mirror. In Episode 8 of “The Return,” upon the unleashing of evil in its raw iteration, we see images of Bob (Frank Silva) enshrouded within the fabric of floating molecules that are being unleashed chaotically through space-time, as if we have been privy to the ill-effects of an atom smashing experiment where Higgs boson “God particles” have been decoupled from the physical universe, causing an irreversible rift in the natural order. This theory bears fruit. In the penultimate episode of “The Return,” our unpredictable English lad Freddie Sykes, with a hand and green glove of superhuman strength, is the only person in the known physical universe who is capable of effectively “atom smashing” the Bob-branded orb of garmonbozia that emerges from Evil Cooper’s corpse, when he is prostrate and slayed in the Twin Peak’s sheriff’s station awaiting imminent, spiritual resuscitation from the Woodsmen.

From these images, we see the prophetic metaphors of good and evil and otherwise innocuous foreshadowing images that seem to have an almost dream-like level of inter-connectivity. One of which is Evil Cooper arm-wrestling and displaying an unbeatable level of physical strength, as pitted against the hand of Freddie, who is able to ultimately “atom smash” Bob, and operate as the hand of good that can overcome the hand of evil. Other such images of intractable evil is the depiction of Woodsman inflicting violent havoc in a radio station (“gotta light?”), but more importantly, is the refrain that is repeated:

“This is the water, and this is the well. Drink full, and descend. The horse is the white of the eyes, and dark within.”

As we know from the Fire Walk With Me refrain from seasons past, Lynch typically repeats phrases of particular importance. And this particular statement, uttered during the unmitigated infliction of violence and sorrow, seems to be the origin story of darkness that inhabits Twin Peaks and the mind of the dreamer. The horse, as we recall, is the image that constantly appears to Sarah Palmer when she is otherwise seemingly drunk or overloaded with prescription medications in Seasons 1 and 2. But it is also the same horse, remarkably, that is presented to us in Episode 18 of the Return, when Cooper/Richard finally arrives in Odessa, Texas, to meet Carrie Page/Laura Palmer. A white horse is depicted on her mantle, near the dead corpse of a man shot in the head by a sub-machine gun that lays idly on the floor, as both Carrie/Laura and Cooper/Richard stand by, seemingly disaffected by the trauma.

The next particularly dispositive image of burgeoning evil is the stilted and uncomfortable image of youthful romance, where a young girl (most likely, Sarah Palmer) displays a shy reaction to a boy who attempts to kiss her. As if suggesting that this innocence is akin to some form of fear or vulnerability, the roach or fly that has emerged from the sub-atomic rift manages to crawl to her residence and nest within her body, suggesting that we have perhaps witnessed the inculcation of evil within Sarah Palmer, and the foundation for the ultimate life of sorrow that her daughter will be forced to endure.

It also suggests that Laura was imported into this “world” by the spirits of the Lodge—i.e., the Fireman/giant—in order to somehow either redress, or manifest, the sorrow and grief (see, supra, “garmonbozia”) that exists within the physical universe. Whereas Sarah is the spiritual inhabitor of great sorrow, Laura is the recipient of it, rather like the sacrificial Christ-like figure. However, as we are led to understand, Laura/Carrie is no adequate redemption for pure evil; rather, she is the pre-ordained and sacrificial recipient of sorrow, no matter what the course of her narrative. Either as Laura Palmer, or Carrie Page, suffering seems to find her, and the trappings around her are one in the same: the horse figurine which relate to Sarah Palmer’s visions in the Palmer house, a dead man with his head splattered across the wall, a life on the lam, an underworld of darkness, an undercurrent of pain.

Just as good and evil has evolved over Twin Peaks’ twenty-five year history, so has the notion of self and the consciousness of being. We see, for the first time in “The Return,” the notion that there is not just a good or bad Cooper as was the dual premise in the first two seasons, but rather, there are additional iterations, such as Dougie Jones, or Richard. Thus, ultimately, who “Cooper” is, and what he represents, seems to be a conglomeration of various iterations or schisms of personality: good, bad, cataonic, virile, and an infinite host of others. When the good Dale Cooper finally emerges from his slumber, at the hands of sticking a fork into an electrical socket and then waking up from a coma, his first order of business is to save the physical universe from Evil Cooper. And yet, once that objective is complete, the business of wrapping-up Twin Peaks with a tidy little bow is simply not possible.

For a fleeting moment, we were made to believe that Cooper could somehow crawl back in time through the help of Phillip Jeffries, and avert the murder of Laura Palmer. Through use of interwoven historical footage from Fire Walk With Me, and dimly lit shots of an aged Sheryl Lee reprising her role as Laura as a teenager, Cooper manages to make his way to the precise moment in time before Laura is killed. Yet, this effort is in vain, as Cooper is unable to rescue Laura from her fate of grief, pain, and sorrow. “Fellas, coincidence and fate figure largely in our lives,” Cooper once said almost excitedly in Owl Cave.

Laura is incapable of salvation no matter what her story, and no matter who she is. Whether on a literal time line or plane, or in the fabric of an over-arching dream, one thing remains evident: Cooper has managed to effectively erase the narrative of Twin Peaks: Season 1 and 2 by erasing Laura’s murder at the hands of Bob. But this, of course, does not remediate the ever-existing sorrow that exists in this world. As noble as Cooper is, even he cannot solve that infinite existential dilemma. Nonetheless, in his effort, as he predicted with Diane before he crossed the 430-mile mark in Episode 18, he now presents as a new version of himself—that is, one who is uncertain, vulnerable, and crestfallen to realize that Sarah Palmer does not reside at the house, and that he cannot thread solve the dream-narrative in a manner that can provide spiritual catharsis.

Rather, Ms. Tremond/Chalfont now reside at the Palmer house, which harkens, of course, to the image of Donna Hayward in Fat Trout Trailer Park trailer, encountering lodge spirits in the form of an old woman (“grandmother”) and a young boy (David Lynch’s son), who holds creamed corn (“garmonbozia”) in his hands and makes it disappear like magic. We learn in the final scene of “The Return” that a “Mrs. Chalfont” sold the “Palmer house” to the current residents, The Tremond’s.

These characters are depicted as spirit beings in Fire Walk With Me as well, and we are left with the distinct impression that though Cooper has perhaps altered the fabric of history in an effort to achieve salvation for himself and Laura, he has left himself inexorably trapped, like Audrey, within a terrible but, at times, beautiful dream of his own manufacture.


Trackbacks for this post

  1. tractor supply ivermectin wormer
  2. generic vidalista prices
  3. does ivermectin work for pinworms
  4. international travel with prescription drugs
  5. canadian pharmacy online sildenafil
  6. buy cheap cialis 20mg online
  7. online dr consultation prescription
  8. cialis for men
  9. ivermectin 6mg
  10. cialis used for pulmonary hypertension
  11. vidalista without a doctor prescription not scam
  12. zinc prophylaxis for coronavirus
  13. amoxicillin 30 capsules price
  14. azithromycin pills 250 mg
  15. best price for viagra 100mg
  16. tadalafil without a doctor prescription
  17. cialis cheapest price uk
  18. viagra from amazon
  19. viagra and cialis cadupi
  20. viagra without a doctors approval
  21. cialis daily dosage
  22. tadalafil package insert
  23. hydroxychloroquine purchase online
  24. is hydroxychloroquine a prophylactic
  25. hydroxychloroquine antiviral effects
  26. does ivermectin kill pinworms
  27. what does prednisone do to your body
  28. dapoxetine india brand
  29. what is a safe dose of aurogra
  30. sildenafil with dapoxetine
  31. over the counter cialis walgreens
  32. purchase cialis canada
  33. cheapest place to buy vidalista
  34. cialis canada online pharmacy
  35. where can you get cialis over the counter
  36. rx tadalafil
  37. sildenafil citrate 50mg
  38. cialis from usa without a prescription?
  39. genuine cialis for sale
  40. calishite 5e
  41. buy stromectol tablets humans
  42. cialis 20 mg
  43. cheapest viagra 100mg
  44. levitra without prescription
  45. bupropion er
  46. side effects of coreg
  47. donepezil 5mg
  48. cephalexin uses
  49. clindamycin hcl 300 mg
  50. sildenafil fast delivery
  51. bimatoprost and latanoprost together
  52. clomid for irregular periods
  53. fluconazole dosing pediatric
  54. domperidone dose
  55. buy cialis dubai
  56. fda approved over the counter ed pills
  57. how to buy viagra cheap
  58. online casino usa legal
  59. tadalafil 10mg generic
  60. buy ivermectin 12 mg tablets
  61. cialis 5mg voucher
  62. zithromax buying
  63. buy ivermectin 3 mg
  64. meritkiing
  65. elexusbet
  66. Eurocasino
  67. madridbet
  68. meritroyalbet
  69. eurocasino
  70. eurocasino
  71. minocycline 100 mg for sale
  72. buy cialis pills
  73. azithromycin 250 price
  74. meritroyalbet
  75. viagra side effects
  76. cialis 100
  77. walmart cialis
  78. tadalafil 40 mg
  79. viagra prescription
  80. 200 mg sildenafil
  81. stromectol medicine
  82. combivent mail order
  83. purchase stromectol
  84. can i buy cialis without a prescription
  85. sildenafil for pah
  86. viagra no prescription
  87. ivermectin cost uk
  88. flccc ivermectin
  89. combivent sale
  90. frontline doctors ivermectin
  91. alliance rx
  92. flcc email
  93. ivermectin 12 mg tablets for sale
  94. ivermectin 3mg
  95. ivermectin
  96. stromectol 3 mg
  97. ivermectin stromectol
  98. stromectol price usa
  99. generic ivermectin cream
  100. stromectol
  101. where can i buy ivermectin
  102. ivermectin for humans
  103. ivermectin india
  104. frontline doctors ivermectin
  105. ivermectin australia
  106. ignition casino legal in california
  107. ivermectin tablets
  108. tadalafil liquid
  109. buy prednisone 10mg sale
  110. cialis goodrx
  111. best generic tadalafil
  112. provigil generico prezzo
  113. stromectol 15 mg
  114. stromectol buy
  115. safe place order viagra online
  116. how to buy cialis without a prescription
  117. buying viagra online
  118. tadalafil 6mg
  119. furosemide 160 mg
  120. buy ivermectin pills
  121. daily generic cialis
  122. cheap generic cialis canadian pharmacy
  123. levitra dosage
  124. ceallias
  125. sildenafil pills prescription
  126. cialis canada for sale
  127. ivermectin 200mg
  128. where to purchase sildenafil pills
  129. sildenafil pills generic brand
  130. cheap cialis india
  131. generic cialis medication
  132. buy prednisone liquid
  133. prednisone 20mg per day
  134. generic cialis drugs
  135. merck pill covid
  136. mylan tadalafil
  137. tadalafil citrate research chemical
  138. stromectol online pharmacy
  139. generic viagra online
  140. prednisone side effects in dogs
  141. what is cialis
  142. online casinos usa
  143. side effects of viagra
  144. sildenafil prices
  145. difference between cialis and levitra
  146. azithromycin for std
  147. my borgata rewards sign in
  148. cialis online pharmacy
  149. how much is ivermectin
  150. ivermectin wikipedia
  151. online casinos free play cash
  152. ivermectin tablets over counter
  153. azithromycin ivp
  154. cialis professional
  155. cialis coupon
  156. generic viagra without a doctor prescription
  157. generic for cialis
  158. omnicef manufacturer
  159. iv zithromax
  160. clindamycin antibiotic
  161. ivermectin mexico
  162. play free win real cash
  163. where to buy ivermectin
  164. ivermectin where to buy
  165. cdc ivermectin
  166. ivermectin tablets for humans for sale
  167. ivermectin 6mg
  168. stromectol tablets 3 mg
  169. keflex online
  170. buy ivermectin
  171. terramycin
  172. augmentin chills
  173. ivermectin 1 cream generic
  174. ciprofloxacin dosages
  175. buy ivermectin 6mg online
  176. ciprofloxacin ribosomal
  177. azithromycin elimination
  178. ivermectin 6 mg otc
  179. ivermectin 12 mg otc
  180. stromectol generic name
  181. buy liquid ivermectin
  182. meritroyalbet
  183. cost of ivermectin lotion
  184. meritking
  185. meritking
  186. trcasino
  187. eurocasino
  188. eurocasino
  189. ivermectin generic cream
  190. purchase cialis
  191. madridbet
  192. luckyland casino play
  193. stromectol medicine
  194. where to buy hydroxychloroquine
  195. ivermectin in canada for humans
  196. ivermectin 500mg
  197. ivermectin usa
  198. child porn